
The freedom of expression and press has long been a contentious issue in Georgia where journalists, both Georgian and foreign, are facing intimidation, threats, and beatings. Reporters without Borders ranks Georgia 120 on the press freedom index scale, worse than Sierra Leone and only one up from Algeria.
And Saakashvili’s government is fully aware of it. In a surprise move, Georgian Parliament Speaker David Bakradze earlier this month publicly apologized for the police beatings of Georgian journalists staging a protest outside Georgia’s State Chancellery.
George Orwell once said that the spoken and written word can be used “as an instrument which we shape for our own purpose.” The Saakashvili government is fully aware of this as well. According to Tamuna Kakulia, a media analyst with Internews Georgia, Georgian television coverage of the war with Russia was tightly controlled and criticism muted.
Immediately following the war, the iron grip on the press remains tightly clenched. Georgia’s former Ambassador to Russia, Erosi Kitsmarishvili, writes in openDemocracy that overt government manipulation has set back press freedom for years.
On March 17, the former spokesperson for the minister of defence, Nana Intskirveli, was appointed as head of news at the privately owned TV station Imedi. The glaring conflict of interest has turned heads, especially at Reporters without Borders, who have condemned the appointment as “an incomprehensible strategic error.”
Imedi was the main opposition news channel. November two years ago, masked riot police with machine guns ransacked the studio as the cameras rolled. The screen then went black but the voice of the newscaster was still audible as he described the attack live according to the New York Times. Now that voice belongs to Saakashvili.
The freedom of opinion, expression, and information without interference is an absolute right. Article 19 (pdf) of the Universal Declaration on Human Rights makes that abundantly clear.
But it will be up to Georgia’s vibrant and diverse civil society along with those brave individuals courageous enough to face down a government that is eroding the most basic freedoms - like assembly - that people enjoy in any healthy democracy.
Since April 9, the beatings and intimidation of demonstrators in Tbilisi has eroded that freedom. Even Georgia’s staunchest ally, the United States, has documented the erosion of human rights. The 2009 Human Rights report available on the US Embassy to Georgia website, says that police brutality and politically motivated detentions , among others, were reported.
An American journalist and human rights activist Jeffrey Silverman who has lived in Georgia for the past 18 years was jumped and grabbed from the street by government thugs in Tbilisi. Two months later, in an email I received today, he says the latest bruises have yet to heal. You can read one of his harrowing experiences here.
As I wrote in my previous post, only two days ago, Norwegian journalist Ragner Skre was attacked by five thugs in ski masks at his apartment in Tbilisi. He escaped with minor bruises but his bag with his notes, a dictaphone, and a wallet was taken.
In his own words, which I will leave you with - Ragner describes the incident:
“At around 22:00 on Friday 19. June 2009 there was a knock on the door, and when I opened it, I saw four or five men with black masks. The one in front pointed a gun at my face. I grabbed the gun and we fought over it while the other attackers forced their way in through the door and pushed me through the corridor and into the kitchen. I got control over the pistol for a short time, maybe ten seconds. They forced me to the floor facing down, and the pistol landed on the floor beside me. Then I noticed that one of them was pointing at me with another pistol. I shouted “help, help”, as there is a ventilation shaft through which our neighbours might hear me, and one of them understands English. Then one of them placed his hand over my nose and mouth so I couldn’t breathe. He was wearing black gloves, as several of the others. He banged my face into the floor with the hand covering my face. One of them brought out a broad adhesive tape, apparantly to gag me with it, but didn’t apply the tape. Then, about five minutes after they had entered the apartment, they left it, slowly, waving their guns around towards me. Afterwards I discovered that they had taken my mobile phone and my bag, which contained a digital camera, a dictaphone, my wallet with a little cash and two Visa cards. I don’t think they searched the apartment, and it bore no signs of it. A glaring green money bag (the kind tourists wear around theyr neck underneath their clothes) lay on the table three meters from the entrance, in plain view. They had not taken it.
Six months ago someone took my camera on the road in the same area. I want to clarify that I do not think there is enough evidence at the current moment to say whether the attack 19. June was thieves who were after my camera or an attack against me because of my work as a journalist. But my first reaction was that it was the latter. If so, I think it is too early to speculate in what the reason could be, since I have not been involved in any investigations which could explain such a violent attack.”